Microsoft Sued Over Xbox 360 Consoles Scratching Discs
In July 2007, a class action in Florida accused Microsoft of selling Xbox 360 consoles that scratched game discs.
Tech Whack Archive 2 min read
Originally reported July 14, 2007. Rewritten for the Tech Whack archive in 2026.
In July 2007, Microsoft was hit with a class-action lawsuit claiming that the Xbox 360 scratched the game discs played in it, sometimes badly enough to make them unusable. The suit was filed in the US District Court for the Southern District of Florida and said thousands of owners had complained to Microsoft about the problem.
Microsoft's response was firm. Spokesman Jack Evans said that out of the millions of Xbox consoles in use, the company hadn't received widespread reports of discs being scratched. Microsoft pointed to its disc replacement programme for its own games, which swapped a damaged disc for a fee of $20, and said it would examine and repair consoles that owners believed had damaged their discs.
Why it mattered
The lawsuit landed at a bad time. Only days earlier, Microsoft had said it expected to take a charge of more than $1 billion to deal with hardware failures in the Xbox 360, the problem players knew as the red ring of death. A second hardware complaint added to the sense that the console had been rushed. The $20 replacement fee also didn't go down well. Readers on our original story argued that charging owners to replace discs their own consoles had damaged was hard to defend, and that the offer only covered Microsoft's own games.
What happened next
The disc-scratching fight went on for a decade. A separate class action over scratched discs, filed in Washington state, was refused class certification by a federal court in 2009. The plaintiffs later tried a legal manoeuvre to appeal that ruling, and the case, Microsoft Corp. v. Baker, went all the way to the US Supreme Court. In June 2017 the court ruled unanimously for Microsoft, holding that plaintiffs couldn't appeal a denial of class certification by dropping their own claims.
The Xbox 360 itself outlived the controversy. Microsoft ended production of new Xbox 360 hardware in April 2016, more than ten years after launch.
For games you can play today in a browser, see our games section.
Related
OnLive Assets Acquired by New Company
Tech Whack Archive
IBM Steps Back From Future Cell Processor Development
Tech Whack Archive
StarCraft II Will Need a Battle.net Account to Play
Tech Whack Archive
Read next
Patient Privacy Rights Urges Support for Health Record Trust Act
Tech Whack Archive


