Friday, November 20, 2026
Archive

SquareTrade Study: iPhone Fails Less Than BlackBerry and Treo

In 2008, warranty firm SquareTrade found the iPhone failed less often in its first year than BlackBerry or Palm Treo phones.

Tech Whack Archive 2 min read

Originally reported November 27, 2008. Rewritten for the Tech Whack archive in 2026.

In November 2008, SquareTrade, a California company that sells extended warranties for electronics, published a study comparing how often smartphones broke down. It looked at 15,000 new phones made by Apple, Research In Motion and Palm, and counted how many failed in their first year.

The iPhone came out best, with a first-year failure rate of 5.6%. BlackBerry phones failed at 11.9%, and Palm's Treo at 16.2%. SquareTrade said it had no ties to any of the three companies. It also admitted a gap in its data: the iPhone was newer, so there wasn't yet enough information on how it held up once the manufacturer's warranty ran out. Its projections still had the iPhone well ahead after 24 months.

Why it mattered

In 2008, the iPhone was barely a year and a half old and still had to prove itself to businesses, which had trusted BlackBerry for years. A common doubt was whether a phone built around a large glass touchscreen could be as durable as one with a physical keyboard. Independent data suggesting the opposite was useful ammunition for anyone arguing that the iPhone was ready for serious use.

What happened next

The market moved the same way as the numbers. Palm was bought by HP in 2010, and HP retired the Palm brand the following year. BlackBerry held on longer, but on September 28, 2016, it said it would stop designing phones itself, and on January 4, 2022, it shut down the services that its older phones depended on. SquareTrade itself is now owned by the insurer Allstate.

Smartphones now come down to iPhone and Android. Here's why some texts are green and some are blue.

Report an error

Related

Read next

Get the Tech Whack newsletter

The biggest tech news in your inbox every week.

We use cookies to give you the best experience on our site.