Apple Updates iTunes to Shut Out PyMusique
In 2005, Apple shut down PyMusique, a program that bought iTunes songs without copy protection. By 2009 Apple dropped music DRM itself.
Tech Whack Archive 2 min read
Originally reported March 22, 2005. Rewritten for the Tech Whack archive in 2026.
In March 2005, Apple moved to block PyMusique, a small program that let people buy songs from the iTunes Music Store without Apple's copy protection. Normally, every song bought on iTunes came wrapped in Apple's FairPlay DRM, which limited where and how it could be played. PyMusique bought the same files but skipped the step that added the lock. One of its developers was Jon Lech Johansen, known for DeCSS, the program that broke DVD copy protection.
Apple fixed the gap within days by changing the store and updating iTunes. "The security hole in the iTunes Music Store which was recently exploited has been closed," the company said, and only customers using iTunes 4.7 would be able to buy music. Apple wouldn't say whether it planned to sue PyMusique's developers.
Why it mattered
DRM was the price the record labels demanded for selling music online, and Apple had to show them it could hold the line. Every hack that got through was a threat to its licensing deals. The fight was also about lock-in. FairPlay songs only played on iPods and in iTunes, which helped Apple keep its lead in both music players and downloads, and rivals such as RealNetworks had already tried and failed to break into that system.
What happened next
The cat-and-mouse game ended on Apple's terms, then flipped. In 2007, Apple began selling DRM-free tracks from EMI as "iTunes Plus", and at Macworld in January 2009 it announced that all music on iTunes would be sold without DRM, after signing deals with the major labels. The thing PyMusique was blocked for doing became the standard for paid downloads.
For today's music and media apps, browse the Tech Whack apps section.
Related
Google Says Google+ Page Analytics Are Coming Soon
Tech Whack Archive
Google Play Store Adds a Section for Tablet Apps
Tech Whack Archive
Google Talk Goes Down for Most Users in July 2012
Tech Whack Archive
Read next
Google Tests Image Results Inside Regular Web Search
Tech Whack Archive



