Texas Sues Vonage Over 911 Calls on VoIP Phones
In 2005 Texas sued Vonage over how its internet phones handled 911 calls, and the FCC soon set rules for every VoIP provider.
Tech Whack Archive 2 min read
Originally reported March 23, 2005. Rewritten for the Tech Whack archive in 2026.
In March 2005, the Texas attorney general sued Vonage, the biggest internet phone company in the US, over how its service handled 911 emergency calls. Vonage had around half a million customers, and the lawsuit said many of them didn't understand that their phones might not reach emergency services the way a landline would.
The problem was technical. Traditional 911 systems are run by local phone companies, and they pass on the caller's location as well as the call. Internet phone providers couldn't do that without agreements with those companies. Vonage asked customers to switch on its 911 feature, but even then, calls often went to an emergency centre's administrative line, which had lower priority and could go unanswered. Texas wanted Vonage to stop advertising that it offered 911 calling, to do more to warn customers, and to pay damages of up to $20,000 for each violation.
Why it mattered
VoIP was replacing landlines in a growing number of homes, and people expected to be able to dial 911 from any phone. A lawsuit from a state attorney general turned that expectation into a legal problem for the whole industry, not just for Vonage.
What happened next
Federal regulators moved within weeks. On May 19, 2005, the FCC adopted rules requiring "interconnected" VoIP services, the kind that connect to the ordinary phone network, to provide enhanced 911. Under the FCC's current rules, providers must include 911 as a standard feature that customers can't opt out of, get each customer's physical address before service starts, pass the caller's number and registered location to the right emergency centre, and warn customers clearly about any limits.
VoIP 911 still depends on your address being up to date and on having power and an internet connection, so the FCC advises keeping a backup phone.
For more on the tech you use every day, see the Tech section.
Related
Samsung Unveils Premium Suite Upgrade for the Galaxy S III
Tech Whack Archive
Sony Brings the Water-Resistant Xperia Advance to the US
Tech Whack Archive
Google Maps for Android Finally Gets Voice Navigation in India
Tech Whack Archive
Read next
PyMusique Is Back Online After Apple's iTunes Block
Tech Whack Archive



