Friday, November 20, 2026
Archive

PyMusique Is Back Online After Apple's iTunes Block

Apple blocked the DRM-free iTunes client PyMusique in March 2005, and its developers had it working again within a day.

Tech Whack Archive 2 min read

Originally reported March 23, 2005. Rewritten for the Tech Whack archive in 2026.

In March 2005, Apple found itself in a quick back-and-forth with PyMusique, a small program that let people buy songs from the iTunes Music Store without the copy protection Apple normally added. Apple pushed out an iTunes update to block it, and within a day the developers had a new version that worked again.

PyMusique was written by Jon Lech Johansen, known as DVD Jon for cracking DVD encryption as a teenager, along with two other programmers. Its starting point was a gap in Apple's store: there was no iTunes for Linux, so Linux users couldn't buy music from it at all. PyMusique talked to the store directly. Buyers still paid for each song, but the file arrived without Apple's FairPlay DRM, so it could be played anywhere. Johansen told CNet that what he did was legal in his country, while admitting that being legal didn't mean he couldn't be sued.

Why it mattered

The fight looked a lot like the one AOL and Yahoo had been having with Trillian and Gaim, third-party chat apps the messaging giants kept locking out by changing their protocols. Every time Apple changed the store, it risked forcing its own paying customers to update iTunes before they could buy anything, while the PyMusique team could answer with a quick patch. Apple hadn't gone to court, and it wasn't clear patching alone could win.

What happened next

Johansen kept working on iTunes DRM. He moved to San Francisco in 2006 and in 2008 launched doubleTwist, software for moving media between devices and formats.

In the end, the argument was settled by the music business rather than by code. At Macworld in January 2009, Apple announced that all music in the iTunes Store would be sold without DRM, at a higher 256 kbit/s quality.

Looking for tools that run on any system? See our apps coverage.

Report an error

Related

Read next

Get the Tech Whack newsletter

The biggest tech news in your inbox every week.

We use cookies to give you the best experience on our site.