Friday, November 20, 2026
Archive

Tiscali Refuses to Name Customers Accused of Music Piracy

In 2006 Tiscali told the British music industry it wouldn't hand over customer details without proper evidence or a court order.

Tech Whack Archive 2 min read

Originally reported July 12, 2006. Rewritten for the Tech Whack archive in 2026.

In July 2006, the UK internet provider Tiscali turned down a request from the British Phonographic Industry, the trade body for the British record labels. The BPI had sent Tiscali information about 17 of its customers and asked the company to act against them, claiming they were sharing music illegally online.

Tiscali, which had about 1.2 million UK customers at the time, said the BPI hadn't made its case. For one customer it had received only parts of a screenshot, and nothing showed that any of the accounts had actually downloaded or shared music. "If you wish to establish that downloading is taking place, please also provide evidence of this," the company wrote back. Its policy was to hand over customers' personal details only when a court ordered it to.

Why it mattered

Record labels trying to act against file-sharers needed internet providers to turn IP addresses into names, because an IP address on its own doesn't identify a person. Tiscali's reply showed that at least some providers weren't willing to police their own customers on the strength of a screenshot, and it set the tone for a long argument over who should enforce copyright online.

What happened next

The argument moved to Parliament. The Digital Economy Act 2010, which received royal assent on April 8, 2010, set up a code under which internet providers would pass on infringement allegations to their customers. Much of that system never came into force, because the rules needed to start it were never passed and were considered shelved by 2014.

Tiscali's UK business didn't last either. Carphone Warehouse bought it in 2009 for £236 million and folded it into TalkTalk, and Tiscali UK closed to new customers in January 2010.

Most people now get their films and music from legal services instead. Here are the best free, legal places to watch movies online.

Report an error

Related

Read next

Get the Tech Whack newsletter

The biggest tech news in your inbox every week.

We use cookies to give you the best experience on our site.